Do you know the specific number of elected and/or appointed officials that have been sworn in using a copy of Marvel’s The Incredible Hulk?
Come on, take a guess. I bet you get it right.
What about Iron Man, how many have been sworn in using that one? Fantastic Four?
Oh, you aren’t big on graphic novels? No problem, tell me instead how many of those folks have been sworn in on Moby Dick. Feel free to substitute Don Quixote if you are trying to avoid sea sickness.
To be honest here, I have not actually done this research but I’m going to go out on a limb and suggest that no one has taken their vow with those books. I will also admit that I am perfectly fine with that.
As a general rule, one is sworn in using a book or object that is particularly meaningful to the individual making the vow. That is not, or at least should not be, news to anyone. Historically, we humans make vows on things that are meaningful to us. I have heard folks telling a story say they “swear on their mother’s grave”. I have heard variations on that using most any family member. I have heard folks say they swear or vow on a stack of bibles, favorite motorcycle, best dog/pet, favorite body part or a special meal. Regardless of the specific words, what they are doing is making a vow on a thing that is so important to them that the idea of them reneging on the vow is inconceivable.
But why? Why do they swear on their mother’s grave rather than on the dead mouse in a trap? I bet you think that is a dumb question. I think so too. The issue is that while it is hyperbolic, I routinely see or hear about a physical analog of the implication. I see absolute demands that people who claim Atheism, Buddhism, Hindu, Sikh, Islam, etc etc, as their belief structure be sworn in using a bible, regardless of how they view the bible. There are actually those who are so mind-numbingly stupid as to insist that someone swear an oath on something that may mean nothing to the individual making the vow.
There are plenty of folk on the planet for whom the bible is just as relevant as the dead mouse in a trap. It makes just as much sense for them to swear on either. It is peak idiocy to demand that you swear an oath on a thing that is precious to me. I’m a huge fan of giant breed dogs and motorcycles. Should Abdul Sayed have to swear an oath on Great Danes because of that? Should he make his vow with a hand on a Laverda Jota?? My guess is that you and they understand why that makes no sense.
The way I see it, it can only be one of a couple of things. Either the folks demanding he (and plenty of others) use a bible for the swearing in are being hypocritical or lying on purpose or they really are that stupid. You cannot make a vow for me. I cannot make a vow for you. We cannot make a meaningful vow based on what someone else holds dear. Something that is absolutely sacred to me might well be meaningless to you or even completely beyond your understanding.
Most of us have heard at some point that the Hindu religion, which is practiced by about 15% of all humans, considers cows to be sacred. Plenty of us who have heard that for decades still slaughter and eat beef. Cows are sacred in their culture but not in ours. The cows in areas where Hindu is the primary religious practice are not significantly different from the cows in the USA. There they are sacred, here they are a sandwich. The cow doesn’t change. What changes is the human’s concept of what is sacred from one culture to the next, from one individual human to the next.
If someone honestly needs this concept explained to them, they should probably not be allowed to make any decisions about their lives until they demonstrate an understanding of the concept. They certainly should not be allowed to participate in governance of the nation at large.